(As Observed, Mostly from a Safe Distance, by Persons Who Were Supposed to Be Doing Something Else)
No, friends. “Orcish diplomacy” is not a contradiction in terms. It is simply a system that assumes violence is already on the table, has in fact been sitting there long enough to get cold, and then asks, with a certain professional curiosity, what else might still be useful before anyone has to reheat it.
Most recorded encounters begin with the same gesture: a display of strength large enough to make further conversation entire optional, if at all possible. This is frequently mistaken, especially by Bards and other persons who enjoy proclamations, for the entire diplomatic program. In practice it is only the opening, and they’re just waiting to see if we say “Banco!” Once both sides have thus reasonably established that hypothetically they could, in theory, kill each other—and, more importantly, that doing so right now would be inconvenient, inappropriate, or not the correct present for the Prince’s birthday—then other negotiation becomes possible.
The fact that most Humans seldom bother with further negotiations is why you’ll frequently find Orcs happily in service to Dark Lords, but that’s (as they say) a different story.
These tend to revolve around three subjects, which our Grand Vizier once summarized, after a particularly long afternoon, as “territory that is not currently on fire, resources that will not keep, and the precise degree to which one group is willing to pretend the other group’s gods are real.” The Dark Lord who had been pretending to read a treatise on theoretical necromancy, looked up long enough to say, “Add a fourth. Whether anyone is going to have to write this down. Writing things down makes them harder to forget later, and forgetting is sometimes the only polite option.”
Treaties exist. They are short. An Orcish treaty rarely exceeds the length of a drinking song and is usually easier to remember when sung, preferably while someone else is still sober enough to keep the goats from wandering off. The terms are concrete: this river is ours until the snow melts, you do not raid our goat pens, we do not raid yours, and if either side breaks the agreement the other side is entitled to be extremely unpleasant about it, with the understanding that “extremely unpleasant” will be defined in the moment by whoever still has the larger number of functional warriors and the smaller number of hangover-related excuses.
There is little interest in abstract principles. There is considerable interest in whether the goats are still there in the morning. The Grand Vizier took her hand out of the till long enough, once, to hav tried to explain this to a particularly earnest White Wizard envoy who had arrived with three scribes, a portable lectern, and a speech about the enduring bonds of mutual trust. The envoy lasted until the part where an Orcish sub-chief pointed out that the goats had, in fact, been moved during the night “for their own safety,” at which point the conversation became significantly shorter and the lectern acquired a new owner.
Hostage exchanges occur more often than most civilized observers expect. The hostages are rarely mistreated in the theatrical sense. They are, however, expected to work. An orcish hostage who cannot carry water, mend armor, or at least refrain from explaining, at length, why the current arrangement is philosophically unsound, is considered a poor investment and may be returned early with a note that is only slightly ruder than the one that accompanied them. The ones who prove useful are sometimes kept longer than the original agreement specified. This is not always regarded as a violation. It is sometimes regarded as an improvement, particularly if the hostage in question has demonstrated any talent for keeping other hostages from complaining.
Marriage alliances are uncommon but not unknown. They function less as romantic gestures and more as mutually assured inconvenience. A chief who has married his daughter to a rival clan’s son has created a situation in which open war would also be a family argument, and orcs, while not opposed to family arguments, prefer them to happen after the fighting rather than during it. The distinction is practical rather than sentimental. Alice once observed that this was one of the few diplomatic tools that required no additional paperwork, which was, in her view, its single greatest advantage.
What orcish diplomacy consistently fails to produce is permanence. Agreements last as long as the conditions that produced them. When the snow melts, when the goats die, when a stronger band appears on the horizon, or when someone on either side simply gets bored and decides that the current arrangement has become an insult to their ancestors, the old terms are revisited with very little ceremony. This is not hypocrisy. It is an accurate assessment of how long most promises remain convenient. Outsiders who treat orcish treaties as binding in perpetuity are usually surprised. Orcs who watch those outsiders be surprised are usually not, though they will sometimes offer the surprised party a drink afterward, on the grounds that surprise is thirsty work.
The system works well enough for people who expect it to be temporary. It works less well for people who arrive with maps, scribes, portable lecterns, and the belief that a signature changes the weather. Orcs have met those people. They have also met the weather. They remain more impressed by the weather.
(There is, it should be noted, a fourth category of outsider: the person who arrives expecting the entire process to be temporary, treats it as such, keeps careful track of the goats, and leaves before anyone has to decide whether the current arrangement has become an insult to anyone’s ancestors. These people are rare. They are also, in Sam’s experience, the only ones who tend to be invited back.)


